Patriotic flicks and studio politics: A record-shattering time in Chinese cinema

Pang-Chieh Ho gives you the latest news from one of Chinaโ€™s most dynamic industries.

Welcome to the first issue of Pang-Chieh Hoโ€™s biweekly roundup of the latest in Chinese movies and television. Think of it as a well-sourced complement to The China Projectโ€™s Society and Cultureย feed, written by Jiayun Feng.


Patriotic action movie shatters Chinaโ€™s box office record

On August 8, Mtimeย reportedย (in Chinese) that Wolf Warriors 2ย (ๆˆ˜็‹ผไบŒ zhร n lรกng รจr) had surpassed Stephen Chowโ€™s The Mermaidย to become the highest-grossing movie in Chinaโ€™s box office history. An action movie with unabashedly patriotic and nationalist overtones, Wolf Warriors 2ย tells the story of an ex-Special Forces operative who is living a life of relative peace in Africa but is forced to step up to save the day when American mercenaries begin to terrorize the civilian communities living there. While the reception of the movie has been mixed, with reviews from RogerEbert.comย and Initium Mediumย panning the movie for its heavy-handed propagandism, that hasnโ€™t stopped Wolf Warriors 2ย from continuing to dominate Chinaโ€™s box officeย (link in Chinese).

image2
Promotional photo of Wolf Warriors 2

The movieโ€™s success is especially remarkable when considering the fact that Chinaโ€™s box office growth has been sluggish since 2016, dropping from an annual average growth rate of 35ย percentย to merely 3.7ย percentย last year, according toย theย Hollywood Reporter. Wolf Warriors 2โ€™s widespread popularity could be attributed to timing, Sixth Toneย suggests, as the movie debuted during a time when peopleโ€™s nationalist sentiments were running high due to border disputes between China and India. Chinese media outlets like Yiqipaidianying, however, haveย contendedย (link in Chinese)ย that the high production values and Hollywood-caliber action sequences wereย someย of the movieโ€™s main drawing points for Chinese audiences.

Read more about Wolf Warriors 2 on The China Project: โ€œDirector of patriotic blockbuster publishes passport scans to prove he is Chineseโ€

Not every state propaganda film, however, has been celebrated in China

Although The Founding of an Army (ๅปบๅ†›ๅคงไธšย jiร n jลซn dร  yรจ), a movie commissioned by the government to commemorate the 90th anniversary of the Peopleโ€™s Liberation Army (PLA), debuted on the same weekend as the similarly patriotic Wolf Warriors 2, the fates of the two movies have been markedly different. Days before the movie premiered, Ye Daying ๅถๅคง้นฐ, film director and grandson of military commander Ye Ting ๅถๆŒบ, took to Weibo to decry the movieโ€™s castingย (in Chinese), particularly the hiring of comedic actors and young, attractive male idols, otherwise known in China as โ€œlittle fresh meatsโ€ (ๅฐ้ฒœ่‚‰ xiวŽo xiฤn rรฒu), in the roles of the movieโ€™s main leads. In his post, Ye accused the movieโ€™s producers of distorting history in favor of profit and entertainment and described the choice of having โ€œeffeminate actors who can barely stand up straightโ€ portray army officers as โ€œdisgraceful.โ€

image1
Promotional photo of The Founding of an Army

Ironically, despite the movieโ€™s attempts to lure young moviegoers with a star-studded cast, The Founding of an Armyย hasnโ€™t fared well at the box office. Yiqipaidianyingย reportsย (in Chinese) that even after the state media regulator encouraged many theaters to give the movie at least a 45ย percentย screen share during its opening weekend and promised exhibitors bonuses if they met the quota, the movie still lagged behind Wolf Warriors 2 by a large margin. Representatives of the movieโ€™s marketing, however, have refuted such claims and toldย the Global Times that the numbers of screens allocated to The Founding of an Armyย was based on market demand and not on any government directive.

Read more about Theย Founding of an Army on The China Project: โ€œControversy over โ€˜fresh meatโ€™ in propaganda filmโ€

China strengthens control on prime-time TV, cuts back on variety and reality shows

On August 5, The Paperย reportedย (in Chinese) that the State Administration of Press, Publication, Radio, Film and Television (SAPPRFT) had issued a new notice regulating prime-time TV broadcasting in China. The latest guidelines from the stateโ€™s top media regulator prescribed an increase of programming about culture, technology, and economics and cutbacks on programs too focused on โ€œentertainmentโ€ and โ€œpolitically sensitive materialโ€ during prime time. Variety and reality shows that relied heavily on the participation of celebrities to boost their ratings were singled out in the notice, and shows that were adapted from foreign variety and reality show formats were bannedย (link in Chinese)ย from prime time.

The SAPPRFT has, in the past few months, become more stringent in the monitoring of movies, TV, and online content. And with the Communist Partyโ€™s National Congress and the 90th anniversary of the founding of the PLA both occurring this year, Chinaโ€™s administration has lately become more aggressive in itsย propagandistic directives. Earlier last month, Sinaย revealedย (in Chinese) that the SAPPRFT had instructed TV stations to stop airing period dramas and dramas starring young idols, genres that are both hugely popular in China. Instead, broadcasters were advised by the administration to air 17 government-approved propagandistic dramasย during prime time in order to foster an atmosphere of political solidarity.

Wang Jianlinโ€™s Hollywood dream hits a snag

The Los Angeles Timesย reportedย on July 27 that Wang Jianlin ็Ž‹ๅฅๆž—, the founder of Dalian Wanda Group and one of Chinaโ€™s richest men, was selling off part of his Qingdao Movie Metropolis complex. The movie metropolis was meant to be the biggest movie complex in the world and was part of Wandaโ€™s many efforts to solidify its position as an industrial powerhouse in the global movie industry. Wangโ€™s sudden sell-off of the Chinese movie complex has been interpreted as part of his companyโ€™s broader plans to reduce debts and embrace an asset-light strategy, a strategy that the Los Angeles Times speculates may be connected to the Chinese governmentโ€™s recent calls for private companies to reduce leverage.

image3
Photograph by Stuart Isett/Fortune Global Forum

The sell-off of the Qingdao Movie Metropolis is only the latest incident in a series of setbacks Wanda has faced expanding its global entertainment empire. Despite Wang Jianlinโ€™s bold declaration last year that his company was interested in acquiring a Hollywood majorย (link in Chinese), Wandaโ€™s plans to purchase Dick Clark Productions and a 49ย percentย share of Paramount Pictures were both scuttled this yearย (link in Chinese), as noted by NDTV. On the side of movie production, its success has been middling, as Legendary Pictures, the studio acquired by Wanda for $1.9 billionย (paywall), has produced more hits than misses as of late, and its chief executive, Thomas Tull, departed the company this January.

Read more about Dalian Wanda on The China Project: โ€œSchadenfreude: The decline of the empire of Wandaโ€