Free speech, Chinese students, and two Canadian campuses
Dear Access members,
Please join us on Monday, February 18, at 10 a.m. EST (11 p.m. Beijing time) on our Slack instant messaging channel, where our own Kaiser Kuo will host a live chat. If you need any help getting logged on to the Slack channel, please email lucas@thechinaproject.com. You can find transcripts of previous Slack chats in the #access_qa_archive channel.
โJeremy Goldkorn and team
1. Free speech, Chinese students, and two Canadian campuses
Most years, there is at least one prominent incident on college campuses in the English-speaking world involving a figure critical of the Chinese government, Chinese students protesting that figure, and questions of where to draw the line on appropriate free speech.
This week, there were two such stories from Ontario province, Canada. Itโs worth reading these reports in full to understand what went on:
-
The Washington Post reports on a protest by Chinese students of a talk by a Uyghur activist, Rukiye Turdush, at McMaster University on February 11.
-
Canadaโs National Post reports on a 10,000-strong petition protesting the election of a Canadian citizen of Tibetan descent, Chemi Lhamo, at the University of Toronto Scarborough to student-union president. ย
The Washington Post obtained WeChat group chat records, apparently leaked by Chinese students more sympathetic to Turdushโs position, showing that the Chinese consulate in Toronto directed the students to โsee whether university officials attended and whether Chinese nationals had organized the talk.โ The students โlater wrote that they sent photos to Chinese officials.โ Emily Rauhala, one of two Post reporters on the story, notes that this is a โrare case of documented coordinationโ between students and P.R.C. consulate officials, whereas in many recent cases, coordination was alleged but not proven, or admitted but the extent was not clear.
As David Mulroney, the former Canadian ambassador to China, tells the Washington Post: โAs with many things involving China, there is a continuum, running from what is acceptable to not acceptableโฆThe fact [the Chinese consulate officials] want to know which academics attend hints at desire to stop academic freedom.โ
Further reporting on college campus free speech issues:
-
Activist accuses Chinese government of meddling after McMaster speech disrupted / CBC News
-
Independent students slam China-backed intimidation on overseas campuses / Radio Free Asia
โLucas Niewenhuis
2. Will China replace crutches?
Hereโs a fascinating read about a company in a way underreported area of Chinese tech: biotechnology. By China Money Network via TechNode:
Chinese startup Fourier Intelligence aims to reinvent the exoskeleton market
For the 85 million disabled in China, obtaining a set of rehab exoskeletons is a far-off dreamโฆ
โThe real hurdle for us is that exoskeleton is not being widely used,โ said Zen Koh, managing director of Fourier Intelligence, during a phone interview with China Money Network in January. โThe main reason is technological constraints: None of the 165 companies, laboratories, and research institutions known to be working on exoskeletons can build a product that can be worn for hours on a daily basis. Imagine buying a several-hundred-thousand-dollar device, but you still need to walk around with crutchesโwhat is the point?โ
This creates a vicious circle, in which low usage and high prices keep most consumers watching on the sidelines. That in turn leads to the inability to scale. What Fourier Intelligence wants to do is to make products at the price level of around $20,000, and then eventually lower it to just a few thousand dollars, making it affordable to all disabled peopleโฆ
[Koh:] โWe believe exoskeleton products eventually will become mainstream in three to five years. Just like with air conditioners, washing machines, and smartphones, you will feel significantly inconvenienced if you are deprived of it.โ
โLucas Niewenhuis
3. Pacific Reset and Huawei update
Compared with the exoskeleton and free speech reads above, the trade war news today is exceedingly bland. The White House statement on this weekโs trade talks in Beijing says as little as Xinhuaโs report on Xi Jinping meeting with the visiting officials, both painting broad strokes and citing unspecified โprogress.โ The Wall Street Journal reports (paywall) that a โmemorandum [of understanding] in the works is expected to cover issues related to Beijing’s offers to purchase more American goods and services, accelerating China’s market-opening efforts in sectors such as financial services and manufacturing, as well as improving its protection of U.S. intellectual-property rights.โ
More links for today related to the Pacific Reset:
-
The negotiations will never end
China and U.S. to Continue Trade Talks Next Week / NYT (porous paywall)
โThe two sides plan to continue negotiations next week in Washington to try to end the trade warโฆ Trump suggested for the second time in a week that he would push the deadline back if the two sides were edging closer to a deal.โ -
Another trade secret theft indictment
Former Coke Scientist Accused of Stealing Trade Secrets for Chinese Venture / WSJ (paywall)
โA Chinese-born scientist was arrested on charges of trying to steal trade secrets from companies doing research with Coca-Cola Co., with the intent to set up a competing venture in China and win a reward from a Chinese government-backed program.โ -
More weird praise of Xi from Trump
Trump praises Chinaโs use of death penalty for drug dealers, implies that the US should follow suit / Shanghaiist
โThe US president also appeared to mock Xi’s accentโ -
Huawei in Britain
It’s complicated, says Britain’s MI6 spymaster on Huawei 5G issue / Reuters -
Huawei in Europe
Telecoms industry calls for Europe-wide network testing regime / Reuters
The trade body GSMA โhas called on European governments to join mobile operators in establishing a testing regime to protect network security without having to resort to the disruptive step of excluding vendors from the market.โ -
Huawei in Poland
China’s Huawei says ready to work with Poland to build trust / Reuters -
The prospect of foreign interference laws in Canada
Why experts say Canada should follow Australiaโs lead on China in wake of Huawei crisis / The Star Vancouver -
Chinese consumers still really, really like fancy Canadian coats
Remember that โChinese boycottโ of Canada Goose jackets? It didnโt happen / SCMP
โCanada Goose Holdings Inc boosted its annual forecast for the second time in six months, signalling its premium down parkas remain popular with Chinese shoppers amid a diplomatic spat between China and Canada and calls for a boycott of the brand.โ
At the end of December, Reuters reported on the successful opening of Canada Gooseโs first shop in China, despite the escalating hostage crisis: Canada Goose’s first China store draws eager crowds despite diplomatic headwinds -
South China Sea and other military hotspots
US commander pushes for more funding to counter Chinaโs influence in Indo-Pacific / SCMP
Admiral Phil Davidson โhas urged Americaโs strategic decision-making body to increase financial investment in the region to counter Chinaโs expanding economic and military influence.โ
โLucas Niewenhuis
4. Real-time censorship for real-time comments
In January, China released new guidelines to tighten its grip on the booming industry of short-video apps, requiring the vetting of all sorts of content before publication. Under the new regulations, the content that is subject to self-censorship on platforms like Kuaishou and Douyin includes not only videosโ titles, languages, and graphics, but also real-time comments written by viewers while they are watching, better known as danmu (ๅผนๅน dร nmรน), or โbullet screens.โ
Today, the Peopleโs Daily published an article (in Chinese) that explains the thinking behind the decision to place danmu under tighter control and how Chinese short-video platforms are coping with the increasing demand of self-censorship.
Click through to The China Project for more details.
โJiayun Feng
—–
Our whole team really appreciates your support as Access members. Please chat with us on our Slack channel or contact me anytime at jeremy@thechinaproject.com.
โJeremy Goldkorn, Editor-in-Chief
Here are the stories that caught our eye this week:
-
The government of Turkey has strongly condemned Chinaโs treatment of Uyghurs, and noted in particular the reported death of folk poet Abdurehim Heyit in prison. In response, Beijing produced a video of a pale but very much alive Heyit saying he is in good health, but is being investigated โfor allegedly violating national laws.” The video has backfired as Uyghurs around the world are now demanding evidence that their relatives in Xinjiang are still alive, using the hashtag #MeTooUyghur.
-
New Zealand has joined the club of Turkey, Canada, Norway, Australia, Poland, the Czech Republic, and Lithuania as a recent target of Beijingโs wrath
-
Zhฤng Yรฌmรณu ๅผ ่บ่ฐ, Chinaโs most famous living director, had a film pulled from the Berlin Film Festival by Chinese authorities. The film is billed as an intimate portrait of a prisoner who escaped from a labor camp during the Cultural Revolution and is on a trek to see a key newsreel in a rural village cinema.
-
โXi Study Strong Nation,โ or Xue Xi Qiang Guo (ๅญฆไน ๅผบๅฝ), became the most downloaded app on Appleโs China store this week. The app, or rather the Party that produced it, demands engagement from users.
-
Anna Lindstedt is now the former Swedish ambassador to China, after Angela Gui reported a bizarre and threatening meeting with unnamed businessmen set up by the ambassador without the foreign ministryโs knowledge. Angela is the daughter of Guรฌ Mวnhวi ๆกๆๆตท, Swedish citizen and seller of books that Chinese leader Xi Jinping doesnโt like, who has been held in custody in China for over a year.
-
The U.S.-China trade talks seem likely to be extended to May, after Donald Trump repeatedly hinted at the possibility, and negotiators reportedly remained at an impasse on important structural issues.
BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY:
-
A solar power plant in space?
Plans for first Chinese solar power station in space revealed / Sydney Morning Herald
โConstruction of an early experimental space power plant has begun in the inland city of Chongqing, China’s Science and Technology Daily reported on its front pageโฆ. Chinese scientists first plan to build and launch small to medium-sized solar power stations to be launched into the stratosphere to generate electricity, between 2021 and 2025.โ -
Trade dispute with Brazil
China imposes anti-dumping tariffs on Brazilian chicken / AFP
โChina announced anti-dumping duties on Brazilian chicken Friday (Feb 15), saying investigations had revealed that poultry imports had done โsubstantive damageโ to the domestic broiler industry. The tariffs โ ranging from 17.8 percent to 32.4 percent โ will take effect from Feb 17 and remain in place for five years, the commerce ministry said.โ -
Hard times for Didi Chuxing
Chinaโs Didi is laying off 15% of its staff / TechCrunch
โChinaโs largest ride-hailing firm Didi plans to let go 15 percent of its employees or about 2,000 people this year, sources told TechCrunch.โ
Didi is axing jobs and could retreat from food delivery and bike sharing / CNN -
Economic stimulus
China tells banks to โincrease financial supportโ for private firms / SCMP
POLITICS AND CURRENT AFFAIRS:
-
Long read on the student Marxists and labor activists
Inside Chinaโs crackdown on young Marxists / FT (paywall)
<div class=”tweet” data-attrs=”{“url”:”https://twitter.com/ericfish85/status/1096159052743139328 “,”full_text”:”That’s quite a photo, showing in red the Marxist student activists who’ve been detained since it was taken in August ft.com/content/fd0874โฆ “,”username”:”ericfish85″,”name”:”Eric Fish”,”date”:”Thu Feb 14 21:27:38 +0000 2019″,”photos”:[{“img_url”:”https://thechinaproject.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/DzZWY7_WsAUQJAo.jpg”,”link_url”:”https://t.co/Afq1GITIBl”}],”quoted_tweet”:{},”retweet_count”:9,”like_count”:16,”expanded_url”:{}}”>
That’s quite a photo, showing in red the Marxist student activists who’ve been detained since it was taken in August ft.com/content/fd0874โฆ
-
MBS to meet with XJP
Saudi crown prince to visit China / AFP
Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, โwho has come under suspicion over an alleged role in the killing of journalist Jamal Khashoggi, will visit next Thursday and Friday and will meet with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Vice Premier Han Zheng.โ -
The Philippine pudding incident
The pudding incident and our China-chummy government: Inquirer / Philippine Daily Inquirer via Straits Times
โAre Filipinos overacting in their frenzied response to the โtahoโ (soy pudding)-throwing incident involving a female Chinese national and a Filipino policeman at the MRT station?โ -
Malaysia-China relations
Malaysia ‘values China’: Mahathir signs up to Xi’s second Belt and Road summit / SCMP
โMalaysiaโs Mahathir Mohamad has become the first world leader to confirm his attendance at Chinaโs second Belt and Road Initiative summit this April, in a move analysts say is aimed at reassuring Beijing of his commitment to the project.โ -
New Zealand-China relations
Huawei ban: Chinese state media claims tourists avoiding New Zealand / The Guardian
โNew Zealand has become the latest target of a propaganda campaign in Chinaโs state-run media, with the English language Global Times newspaper claiming that tourists are cancelling their holidays in retaliation for the country banning Huawei from being involved in the 5G rollout.โ
No evidence of China retaliation for Kiwi exports: govt officials / New Zealand Herald
โThe Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade is reassuring New Zealand exporters that their products continue to be cleared into China, as fears simmer that Kiwi companies are on a trade blacklist following access problems for fresh salmon shipments.โ
How to repair damage to 2019 China-New Zealand Year of Tourism / New Zealand Herald -
Chinese protest in Spain
Chinese protest in Madrid against mass bank account freeze / AFP
โHundreds of Chinese citizens staged a rare protest Friday (Feb 15) at an office of Spain’s BBVA bank in Madrid, angrily denouncing that their personal accounts had been frozen without prior warning. Waving Chinese and Spanish flags, the protesters shouted โracist BBVAโ and โwe want justice,โ carrying banners reading โstop banking racism.โโ -
Sweden ambassador incident
Sweden FM says sheโs upset by ambassador to China case / AP -
Censorship to protect the PLAโs image
China considers criminal charges, including jail time, for military rumor-mongers / SCMP -
Meng Hongwei case aftermath
Wife of missing former Interpol chief removed from political body / Caixin
โGao Ge (also known as Grace Meng), the wife of former Interpol president Meng Hongwei [who was disappeared by the National Supervision Commission last October], was removed from the 12th Shandong Committee of the Chinese Peopleโs Political Consultative Conference, the region’s leading political advisory body to the government and for Communist Party affairs, according to an official statement issued in January but only recently discovered.โ -
Evolution of propaganda
How official Chinese propaganda is adapting to the social media age as disaffection spreads among millennials / SCMP
SOCIETY AND CULTURE:
-
Perceptions of Chinese tourists
In tour of Australia, Chinese admire clean air but bemoan lack of hot drinking water / NYT (porous paywall) -
Photography
Through her lens: Wang Yingyingโs quest for self-awareness / Sixth Tone
โPhotographer Wang Yingying shares her insights on beauty standards and what it means to turn 40.โ -
Online obituaries and taboos about death
Weiboโs digital graveyard: Remembering the dead on Chinese social media / What’s on Weibo
โWith Chinaโs rapid digitalization and flourishing online media environment, thereโs one crucial societal topic that, although taboo, also now finds its place on Chinese social media: [a Weibo account called โThe Deadโ (@้่ ๅฆๆฏๅคซdead)] collects the stories of the dead and writes their online eulogies. In doing so, they are trying to break long-standing taboos around death in China.โ -
Demolition of lakeside houses in Dali
How Daliโs tourism dream was reduced to rubble / Sixth Tone
Last December, the city undertook โan initiative that razed all buildings located within 15 metersโ of the shores of Erhai Lake. Sixth Tone reports that โthis sometimes meant that the bulldozers plowed through part of the [buildings], leaving sections outside the 15-meter mark standing. More than 1,800 homes and inns were affected by the policy.โ -
A live streamer, now dead
Chinese live stream daredevil killed in bridge jump as camera rolled on his final stunt / SCMP
โA man in eastern China was killed as he tried to impress his internet fans by jumping from a bridge into a river, the City Express reported.โ -
Public urination
Chinese tourist stirs anger after child urinates on floor at Forbidden City in Beijing / SCMP -
John Chan โ straddling cultural divides in the Chinese-speaking world
Sic transit gloria mundi โ Ten years of a prosperous age / China Heritage
โOn 7 February 2019, the WeiBo publication NGOCN featured an interview with Chan Koonchung (้ณๅ ไธญ, b. 1952, also known by his English name, John Chan), the author of In an Age of Prosperity. The translation of that interview [in this post] is part of our China Heritage Annual 2019, the topic of which is Translatio Imperii Sinici โ intimations of empire in modern China.โ -
Music for the Jews who fled to Shanghai
Wu Feiโs Hello Gold Mountain illuminates a story of the Holocaust / Nashville Scene
โHello Gold Mountain, Wuโs new requiem, [will] premiere Feb. 23 at Vanderbilt University courtesy of the alt-classical group chatterbird. Arranged for a small ensemble of 15 musicians, singers and a conductor, the work celebrates the lives of Jewish refugees who fled Europe during WWII and found sanctuary in Shanghai, China.โ
VIDEO ON SUPCHINA
When hip-hop dance is infused with fireworks!
Bo Tao is an amateur hip-hop dancer in Guangdong, China, who likes to share his dance moves on Kuaishou, an online video app. He recently came up with the idea to put fireworks under his shoes and dance. The videos of him dancing with fireworks went viral on the internet, with almost 5 million views per video. What a great way to end the Chinese New Year!
We also published the following videos this week:
FEATURED ON SUPCHINA
โThe People’s Republic of Desire,โ reviewed
Originally founded as a gaming chat site in 2005, YY.com has become one of the biggest streaming sites in China, with more than 300 million users. For Chinaโs poor and ordinary, streaming represents a shot at fame and fortune they could never achieve working their usual jobs. The countryโs newfound obsession with streaming is the subject of The Peopleโs Republic of Desire ไฝ ไบบ็, the latest documentary by filmmaker Hao Wu ๅด็.
What the ruck? Huawei rugby ad catches flak in New Zealand
In this week’s China Sports Column: International Ski Federation president Gian-Franco Kasper is under fire, athletes around the world send Chinese New Year greetings, and Huawei gets clever with a rugby-related ad in New Zealand.
Love in rural China: Mother and daughter
In 2018, Clarinda Blais spent nine months living in Sanpi, a small village in Huangchuan County, Henan, about 230 kilometers from Wuhan. She returned this year to spend the Spring Festival with her host family and further explore a question: What is love in rural China? This five-part series looks at “love” and the way it manifests itself in five kinds of relationships. The first piece is about a 17-year-old high school senior, Fu Bingyu ็ฆๅฐ็, and her mother.
Love in rural China: The auntie of Sanpi
This story is about Sun Jieping, a 43-year-old woman who attempted suicide five years ago when her husband revealed he kept mistresses. She has since found purpose through taking care of the villageโs children.
Love in rural China: An engagement
This story is about Sun Weiwei ๅญ่่ and Yu Qiqi ไฝๅฅๅฅ, a young couple who recently became engaged.
Love in rural China: Like father, like son
This story is about Yu Xiaoqing ไฝๆ้, 22, and his father, whose expectations for him are a source of friction.
Love in rural China: โHave you eaten?โ
This is the last part in a five-part series, about Sun Jieying ๅญๆฐ่ฅ and Lei Zhengya ้ทๆญฃไบ, who were born and raised in Sanpi, got married there, own a farm there, and raised three children and four grandchildren there, over the course of 50 years of marriage.
Taiwanโs indigenous are still seeking justice on the democratic side of the Taiwan Strait
Last month, 31 indigenous representatives of Taiwan signed an open letter condemning the โhegemonyโ of Xi Jinping โ but donโt interpret that as full-throated support for Taiwanโs current government. For many of the island’s half-million indigenous residents, cross-straits politics is secondary to more pressing, long-overlooked issues they face at home, everything from education to suicide rates to government restrictions on their claim to ancestral land.
โPatriot Act with Hasan Minhajโ highlights Chinaโs #MeToo movement, online censorship, and Uyghur repression
In the first episode of its second season, Netflixโs current events and culture satire show Patriot Act with Hasan Minhaj focuses on censorship in China. Minhaj explains the topic through the lens of how Chinaโs #MeToo feminist activists have fought the system and built arguably the largest social movement in the country since 1989. He also highlights China’s imprisonment of a million Uyghur Muslims, a topic that receives barely more attention on American television than it does on Chinese.
Fight sexual harassment: A poster featuring Li Tingting of Chinaโs Feminist Five
Employers in New York State are required by law to adopt a sexual harassment policy that meets certain minimum standards. Among other requirements, according to this new policy, employers must display information about these standards in a publicly available place. Here at The China Project, a proudly feminist Brooklyn-based company, we are of course happy to oblige โ and give a shout-out to Chinese feminists while weโre at it. Our poster model is Li Tingting (a.k.a. Li Maizi), one of China’s Feminist Five.
Kuora: The most overlooked moments in 20th-century Chinese history
The rise of technocracy in China; Sino-U.S. strategic cooperation in the 1980s vis-ร -vis the Soviet Union; the conservative, opposition reaction to reform and opening up; everything to do with warlordsโฆ There are many facets of 20th-century Chinese history that get short shrift in typical English-language history texts. Kaiser Kuo takes a look at several of them in this week’s Kuora.
SINICA PODCAST NETWORK
Sinica Podcast: Chinaโs ethnic policy in Xinjiang and Tibet: The move toward assimilation
This week on the Sinica Podcast, Jeremy and Kaiser speak with Tashi Rabgey, research professor of international affairs at George Washington University and director of the Tibet Governance Project. They are joined by returning guest Jim Millward, professor of history at Georgetown University and renowned scholar of Xinjiang and Central Asia. This episode focuses on their respective areas of expertise: human rights violations in the Xinjiang region; the P.R.C. approach to ethnic policies in Tibet and Xinjiang, referred to on this show as minzu (ๆฐๆ mรญnzรบ) policy; and the assimilation and securitization of both regions.
-
Subscribe to the Sinica Podcast on Apple Podcasts, Overcast, or Stitcher, or plug the RSS feed into your favorite podcast app.
Ta for Ta: Episode 14: Samantha Kwok
On the latest Ta for Ta, Samantha Kwok talks about why her passion is to help young graduates and professionals make genuine connections with potential employers, and how to empower them to take control of their own career development. She is the founder of JingJobs, an online and offline platform dedicated to connecting China-focused startups and fresh bilingual talent.
-
Subscribe to Ta for Ta on Apple Podcasts, Overcast, or Stitcher, or plug the RSS feed into your favorite podcast app.
ChinaEconTalk: Chinaโs foothold in Indiaโs tech ecosystem
Today, nearly half of the top 100 apps in India’s Google Play store are made by Chinese companies. To explore this phenomenon, we spoke with Shadma Shaikh, a writer at Factor Daily. She and Jordan examine the multiple different aspects of Chinaโs growing presence in Indiaโs technology space. They also discuss the successes and failures of Chinese tech companies in India, the strategies that helped those companies find success, and the unique features of Indian culture (such as multiple languages), which have created difficulties for Western and Chinese tech companies that are eager to gain access to the Indian tech market. ย
-
Subscribe to ChinaEconTalk on Apple Podcasts, Overcast, or Stitcher, or plug the RSS feed straight into your favorite podcast app.
PHOTO OF THE DAY
Beihai at dusk
It snowed recently in Beijing, leading to some wonderfully fresh views of familiar landmarks. Hereโs the famous White Pagoda (็ฝๅก bรกi tว) at Beihai Park near the heart of Beijing, caught in just the right waning light. This picture was taken by Eric Favreliere.